I have an electric one and it works fine but when I take it off either of my two dogs, they will be silent for a couple of days but then they start barking again. I don’t like to be the AHOLE neighbor with the dogs that disturbs people, and it bothers me, so I have 0 tolerance for barking unless they are inside and I am playing with them
Do the spray ones work better? If I don’t find a solution soon I just may keep it on permanently.

